microbiologynews feature
José R. Penadés
More in life sciences and medicine
- Adam Johnsonmedicine, 9 Jun 2026
- Seyed Yahya Shirazineuroscience, 2 Apr 2026
- Rob Patrogenomics, 15 Feb 2026
What they did
Penadés's team tested Google's AI co-scientist system, at Google's request, on a question the lab had already answered experimentally but not yet published. The system returned five hypotheses, and the most plausible coincided with the lab's own hypothesis about a mechanism of gene transfer between bacteria, which has since been confirmed experimentally. He says the system also proposed other hypotheses the team is now working on.
In their words
"Google’s AI co-scientist system put forward five hypotheses in response to our question and the most plausible of them coincided exactly with our own hypothesis, which we have now confirmed experimentally."
"In just two days, Google’s AI co-scientist platform has formulated the same hypothesis which took us seven years of hard work to validate."
Lessons they draw
- Test on a question whose answer you already know from unpublished work (Penadés, as described by CEU).
- He says an AI-generated hypothesis can take years to validate, so hypothesis quality matters (Penadés, as described by CEU).
- He treats the output as hypotheses to test experimentally, not as results (Penadés, as described by CEU).
Limits of this account
University press page (secondary report) about a vendor-invited retrospective test; timings ("two days", "seven years") are the researcher's claims and other coverage gives different figures.