# José R. Penadés

- Researcher: José R. Penadés
- Role: Department of Infectious Disease, Imperial College London; lecturer at CEU UCH (as stated by CEU)
- Field: microbiology
- Tools: Google AI co-scientist
- Published: 2025-03-04
- Source: https://medios.uchceu.es/actualidad-ceu/en/professor-jose-r-penades-tests-google-co-scientist-system/
- Older account (before March 2026). Latest flagship models when written: . Latest now: Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6.1 Sol. Agent tools have also changed since, so check whether a limitation reported here still applies.

## What they did

Penadés's team tested Google's AI co-scientist system, at Google's request, on a question the lab had already answered experimentally but not yet published. The system returned five hypotheses, and the most plausible coincided with the lab's own hypothesis about a mechanism of gene transfer between bacteria, which has since been confirmed experimentally. He says the system also proposed other hypotheses the team is now working on.

## In their words

> "Google’s AI co-scientist system put forward five hypotheses in response to our question and the most plausible of them coincided exactly with our own hypothesis, which we have now confirmed experimentally."

> "In just two days, Google’s AI co-scientist platform has formulated the same hypothesis which took us seven years of hard work to validate."

## Lessons they draw

- Test on a question whose answer you already know from unpublished work (Penadés, as described by CEU).
- He says an AI-generated hypothesis can take years to validate, so hypothesis quality matters (Penadés, as described by CEU).
- He treats the output as hypotheses to test experimentally, not as results (Penadés, as described by CEU).

## Limits of this account

University press page (secondary report) about a vendor-invited retrospective test; timings ("two days", "seven years") are the researcher's claims and other coverage gives different figures.
