# Rayed AlGhamdi

- Researcher: Rayed AlGhamdi
- Role: Researcher, King Abdulaziz University (affiliation as recorded by Crossref)
- Field: qualitative methods, information systems (e-commerce interview data)
- Tools: Claude Code
- Published: 2026-01-19
- Source: https://doi.org/10.1177/16094069261462093
- Older account (before March 2026). Latest flagship models when written: Claude Opus 4.5 and GPT-5.2. Latest now: Claude Opus 5.5 and GPT-6.1 Sol. Agent tools have also changed since, so check whether a limitation reported here still applies.

## What they did

AlGhamdi took qualitative interview data from a doctoral study on e-commerce, originally coded by a human in NVivo in 2012, and ran four independent thematic analyses with Claude Code in 2026. Two prompting strategies were compared, general prompts and structured multi-phase prompts. Agreement with the human analysis was scored with F1 at both code level and theme level, and consistency between AI sessions was checked by bidirectional mapping of session pairs. The published abstract reports code-level F1 between 55.9% and 87.6% (structured prompts averaged 83.1%, general prompts 59.2%) and theme-level alignment of 90.9% to 100%.

## In their words

> "At the code level, AI outputs showed considerable variability, with F1 Scores ranging from 55.9% to 87.6%"

> "although AI-generated codes may differ across sessions and from human coding, the resulting thematic structures converge reliably."

> "AI-assisted analysis can support theme development when structured prompting and human oversight are maintained"

## Lessons they draw

- Evaluate agreement at two levels: exact code agreement was unstable, but themes were stable across sessions (AlGhamdi).
- Structured multi-phase prompting raised code-level agreement from 59.2% to 83.1% on average (AlGhamdi).
- Keep human oversight; strict code-level agreement may not be needed for reliable themes (AlGhamdi).

## Limits of this account

Abstract only, taken from the Crossref record of the DOI (the SAGE page itself returned HTTP 403 to a scripted fetch; the DOI resolves through Crossref). The abstract does not name the Claude model or Claude Code version, so `tools` records only what is stated. One dataset, one author, and the human baseline is the same author's reanalysis target; the abstract does not say how the reference coding was validated. Journal: International Journal of Qualitative Methods (per search result; not checked on the publisher page).
